New Dockers available

[hvymetal]

Originally Posted by randyth

I found these new Docker images (thanks!) and have been trying them out in Container Station on my QNAP NAS. The only issue I appear to have is that I can't get Comskip to run. I installed the Commercial Detector UI plugin, which in turn installed the Commercial Detector and Comskip Playback plugins. But selecting a video and choosing "Run Comskip" does nothing.

I do not have these issues with the "old" stuckless/sagetv-build Docker image.

Any ideas?

I think the older docker allowed the windows version to work with WINE. For some reason WINE even though installed is not working with the plugin which uses the windows version by default.

With the ComSkip UI installed if you select not to run with WINE and native then point the location for comskip to /opt/comskip it will run the linux version.

[randyth]

Originally Posted by hvymetal

I think the older docker allowed the windows version to work with WINE. For some reason WINE even though installed is not working with the plugin which uses the windows version by default.

With the ComSkip UI installed if you select not to run with WINE and native then point the location for comskip to /opt/comskip it will run the linux version.

That was totally it! Thanks so much.

[jusjoken]

Originally Posted by hvymetal

I think the older docker allowed the windows version to work with WINE. For some reason WINE even though installed is not working with the plugin which uses the windows version by default.

With the ComSkip UI installed if you select not to run with WINE and native then point the location for comskip to /opt/comskip it will run the linux version.

Should I look at removing the wine stuff and make some changes to run the Linux version??? What would those changes be?

K

[nyplayer]

EDIT ...

I got SageTV working on my synology ... using command below ...

sudo docker run --name=SageTV --net=host --env TZ=America/Los_Angeles sagetvopen/sagetv-server-opendct-java11

The Problem is I need to make changes to OPENDCT and Sage Properties but I seem not to be able to locate them.

[hvymetal]

Originally Posted by nyplayer

EDIT ...

I got SageTV working on my synology ... using command below ...

sudo docker run --name=SageTV --net=host --env TZ=America/Los_Angeles sagetvopen/sagetv-server-opendct-java11

The Problem is your need to make changes to OPENDCT and Sage Properties but I seem not to be able to locate them.

Because you never mapped it to external directory. Try using the following that emulates what is in the Unraid templete. This has not been tested but should work and can be adpated for your use case.

docker run -d \
  --name=SageTV \
  --net=host \
  -e TZ=America/Los_Angeles \
  -e VERSION=latest \
  -e JAVA_MEM_MB=1024 \
  -e OPT_GENTUNER=Y \
  -e OPT_COMMANDIR=N \
  -e OPT_LIRC=N \
  -e OPT_COMSKIP=Y \
  -e OPT_SETPERMS=Y \
  -p 8080:8080 \
  -p 9091:9091 \
  -p 7818:7818 \
  -p 8270:8270 \
  -p 31100:31100 \
  -p 31099:31099 \
  -p 16867:16867 \
  -p 16869:16869 \
  -p 16881:16881 \
  -p 42024:42024 \
  -v /mnt/user/appdata/sagetv:opt/sagetv \
  -v /mnt/user/sagemedia/:/var/media \
  -v /mnt/user/media/videos:/var/mediaext \
  -v /mnt/user/media/tv/:/var/tv \
  -v /mnt/user:/unraid \
  -v /mnt/user/appdata/opendct/etc:/etc/opendct \
  -v /mnt/user/appdata/opendct/log:/var/log/opendct \
  -v /mnt/user/appdata/opendct/opt:/opt/opendct \
  sagetvopen/sagetv-server-opendct-java11

The templetes can be found. In case I missed something

https://github.com/OpenSageTV/unRAID.../sagetv-server

[hvymetal]

Originally Posted by jusjoken

Should I look at removing the wine stuff and make some changes to run the Linux version??? What would those changes be?

K

My perference is leave Wine out since it adds an additional 400mb of overhead when installed. After closer looking at it it looks like Stuckless never installed wine only but had a man in the middle script to fake that it was installed. It would intercept the commands so it could launch the native comskip. I think he might have done this so the plugin would work reguardless of the proper settings for the plugin. For some reason the script does not work with the new docker. I think the fix would be putting the native comskip in the enviroment path. Also a workaround would be using the proper setting by not running it wine and the proper path for the native comskip.

#!/usr/bin/env bash

# this is hack to get comskip plugin in linux to work by faking wine
# all this does remove wine and execute the args passed to wine
# eventually the plugin for linux, needs to be changed

CMD=$1
shift
"$CMD" "$@"

I would rather see comskip get a native compiled version updated. The advantage of using wine the comskip plug in will work without configuration modifications and the comskip bundled with the plugin.

The advantage native linux is it should run in theory faster with less overhead. Disadvantage it needs to be compiled each update as precompiled version are not offered.

[KeithAbbott]

Originally Posted by hvymetal

My perference is leave Wine out since it adds an additional 400mb of overhead when installed. After closer looking at it it looks like Stuckless never installed wine only but had a man in the middle script to fake that it was installed. It would intercept the commands so it could launch the native comskip. I think he might have done this so the plugin would work reguardless of the proper settings for the plugin. For some reason the script does not work with the new docker. I think the fix would be putting the native comskip in the enviroment path. Also a workaround would be using the proper setting by not running it wine and the proper path for the native comskip.

#!/usr/bin/env bash

# this is hack to get comskip plugin in linux to work by faking wine
# all this does remove wine and execute the args passed to wine
# eventually the plugin for linux, needs to be changed

CMD=$1
shift
"$CMD" "$@"

I would rather see comskip get a native compiled version updated. The advantage of using wine the comskip plug in will work without configuration modifications and the comskip bundled with the plugin.

The advantage native linux is it should run in theory faster with less overhead. Disadvantage it needs to be compiled each update as precompiled version are not offered.

When I moved from the stuckless docker(s) to jusjoken's docker, I did the "in-place" upgrade described in this post: https://forums.sagetv.com/forums/sho...9&postcount=11. Comskip continues to work for me (didn't skip a beat), and my "Run comskip natively" setting is set to False.

[nyplayer]

Originally Posted by hvymetal

Because you never mapped it to external directory. Try using the following that emulates what is in the Unraid templete. This has not been tested but should work and can be adpated for your use case.

docker run -d \
  --name=SageTV \
  --net=host \
  -e TZ=America/Los_Angeles \
  -e VERSION=latest \
  -e JAVA_MEM_MB=1024 \
  -e OPT_GENTUNER=Y \
  -e OPT_COMMANDIR=N \
  -e OPT_LIRC=N \
  -e OPT_COMSKIP=Y \
  -e OPT_SETPERMS=Y \
  -p 8080:8080 \
  -p 9091:9091 \
  -p 7818:7818 \
  -p 8270:8270 \
  -p 31100:31100 \
  -p 31099:31099 \
  -p 16867:16867 \
  -p 16869:16869 \
  -p 16881:16881 \
  -p 42024:42024 \
  -v /mnt/user/appdata/sagetv:opt/sagetv \
  -v /mnt/user/sagemedia/:/var/media \
  -v /mnt/user/media/videos:/var/mediaext \
  -v /mnt/user/media/tv/:/var/tv \
  -v /mnt/user:/unraid \
  -v /mnt/user/appdata/opendct/etc:/etc/opendct \
  -v /mnt/user/appdata/opendct/log:/var/log/opendct \
  -v /mnt/user/appdata/opendct/opt:/opt/opendct \
  sagetvopen/sagetv-server-opendct-java11

The templetes can be found. In case I missed something

https://github.com/OpenSageTV/unRAID.../sagetv-server

Thanks that is exactly what I was looking for now I can setup Sage on a shared folder on the NAS.

EDIT working great now ... got everything going OTA Cable Pluto TVE with XMLTV. For environmental Variables I just use the GUI in Synology.

sudo docker run --name=SageTV --net=host --volume /volume1/MyShares/sagetv:/opt/sagetv --volume /volume1/MyShares/sagemedia:/var/media --volume /volume1/MyShares/videos:/var/mediaext --volume /volume1/MyShares/tv:/var/tv --volume /volume1/MyShares/opendct/etc:/etc/opendct --volume /volume1/MyShares/opendct/log:/var/log/opendct --volume /volume1/MyShares/opendct/opt:/opt/opendct --env TZ=America/Los_Angeles sagetvopen/sagetv-server-opendct-java11

[nyplayer]

Found a Problem with Java 11 OPENDCT properties ..


I had to change every instance of consumer=opendct.consumer.DynamicConsumerImpl to opendct.consumer.FFmpegTransSageTVConsumerImpl

This was Causing the MINIClient EXOPLAYER on FireStick 4K MAX to fail when playing MPEG2. It would instantly crash.


Before I moved to docker the default was always opendct.consumer.FFmpegTransSageTVConsumerImpl.


PS any recordings prior to the change I had to remux to MKV to play them.