![]() |
|
General Discussion General discussion about SageTV and related companies, products, and technologies. |
![]() |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread | Display Modes |
#121
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
Also, BTW, there are tweaks/addons for MC as well for many things. You can get commercial skipping to work, there are caller id apps, home automation, etc. Last edited by heatvent; 05-08-2009 at 02:08 PM. |
#122
|
|||
|
|||
What are your hardware specs, btw? Are you using onboard video?
I just moved over from MCE2005 where you have to configure the registry if you want more than 2 tuners and such. I think that stuff is fun, so I'm not going to complain about it. Trust me, babgvant knows all about Microsoft's media center ![]() Last edited by MitchSchaft; 05-08-2009 at 02:11 PM. |
#123
|
|||
|
|||
I mean you started using 7MC on windows 7, baked in driver support is much better in 7 than vista and xp.
That said the first time I setup 7MC my PC BSOD'd, had to pull down updated drivers for my tuner. I still can't get QAM tuning to work perfectly for all channels... One problem with HTPC is that everyones experience is unique, what's crazy easy for you could be a PITA for me. Quote:
Bottom line, if it works better for you and meets your needs - go for it. I think most of us who are here value the flexibility and features that Sage offers over some incremental setup pain. Quote:
![]() |
#124
|
|||
|
|||
Alright I always love to throw my hat in this argument
I have used media center since day one when the made me by a oem pc to get it mother:$;&!! It takes allot of tinkering to get it like I liked it then I decided nothing but hd would do so I had to buy another oem pc for cablecard mother ![]() I used custom rigs extenders and all the bells in whistles Babgvant got me started testing sage by his blogs You will never see DVD or bluray streaming to extenders from media center IMHO That and drm brought me over to sage and I haven't looked back sense But to each his own |
#125
|
|||
|
|||
Well I'm gonna throw my 3 cents out there (and as I look back on my post apparently I'm gonna be a windbag).
I used mce then vmc. Loved it! It worked, did what I wanted. Was a lot more configurable than the Bell ExpressVu boxes I had. Then HD became an issue because I really wanted it in my media server. HD-PVR was coming out and VMC was not gonna support it. At the time they said windows 7 might support it *when* it comes out. A little bleak. Not to mention the hostility I saw from TheGreenButton users towards users who wanted HD-PVR cababilities. So I switched to Sage, around Aug 2008. It was rocky for the whole family. Not as smooth as I envisioned but we made a go of it. Don't get me wrong, I found VMC a lot more stable than Sage, when Sage has problems it goes down hard. But, then again I'm doing a lot more with it than I ever did with VMC. I love sagetvclient, the equivalent WebGuide for VMC would throttle the server to 100% usage due to transcoding (2.13GHz core 2 duo). Plus now I have a USB-UIRT w/remote so now my 24" monitor can act as a TV on the fly if I want it to. The extenders are slick. No longer when you turn on an extender (xbox 360) it becomes the focal point of the room. Love the blu-ray support, although I only got into blu-ray since I setup Sage. One thing that people may not consider or think of is the configurability of commercial skip. I love it, my wife *hates* it. With Sage we get the best of both worlds. By default I turn it off, then on my shows I toggle it on. I intend to make my own pet project of developing, from the ground up, interface that suits my family needs. This kind of thing is just not possible with MS. With all my blabble above I am just pointing out what *I* see differences between the two. And, I'm not trying to say MS is BAD and Sage is GOOD, but just look beyond the shiney objects to the real application. And remember, when MS released the 'TV pack' they alienated all of their VMC user base because you could only get it (legally) through OEM. And finally "down with NBC", hehe, that's personal. |
#126
|
|||
|
|||
Quote:
![]() BTW that is a seriously scary look cat! |
#127
|
|||
|
|||
He just looks that way. He's the sweetest cat ever
![]() |
#128
|
||||
|
||||
Win7MC Would be a disaster for me
It took me a while to make my PC Server - TV work well but it always crashed every couple of days. Then I purchased 2 Sage HD200 extenders.
WOW! After a few beta release updates I ran for 3 weeks with not a single hangup. With Sage I have 2 ATSC cards, 1 HDPVR plus I have DVDs, Blue Rays and Home HD Movies on my hard drive. We can Record HD-OTA or HD-Dish Content (Convert with Sage) and burn to DVD backup or Blue Ray(too expensive now). We can watch DVDs and Blue Ray with Sage HD200 from Server(Running Sage) on HardDisk. I am still running WinXP and recently did a manual Windows update that killed several web sites in explorer and made Sage TV very unstable. Fortunately I am running Norton Ghost and was able to install a previous image. I then turned off windows update. Sage Responds to user requested Features. Maybe not as quickly as we all would like but they are striving to improve features and extend wider support with every release. Try to get microsoft to support the HD-PVR and see where you get. Any Windows VRM, MCE etc would take me back to where I was 4 years ago before Sage. Who cares about the UI? Apperently the other 90%. Someday the Windows MCE users are going to try to watch an HD OTA show and get a message that they do not have permission to record the show. Just wait it is coming. Has any one ever tried to record HD Radio? Now after 2 Hardware products HD-100 and HD-200. I am now ready for the Sage Do it All PVR Server Box. - Consumer PVR with 2 TB and closed (Linux OS, or WHS) with Sage GUI - Expandable High Speed Storage (USB or ESATA) - Hauppauge Dual Tuner ATSC card - New Sage Dual Tuner HD-PVR like Card (Component Video Encoder) - Firewire Support for external box control - Integrated USB UIRT Support VIA USB - 2 X 1 Gbps Ethernet Port - HDMI, DVI, VGA, Component out - Key Board support (for the tweaker inclined) - 6 USB ports, 2 Component IN, 2 Coax In (ATSC ) ![]()
__________________
SERVER/Endcoder: ASUS M2NE,AMD 5600, 4G Ram, ATI 3850, 10 TB, Antec P180 Case OS/Software: Win XP SP3 (32bit), Smart Defrag, Care, Windows Defender, Sage 7.1.5 Encoders ATSC: HVR 1800 (PCIE), HVR2250(PCIE) Satelite: Dish VIP622 Bronze HD Pacakge, HD PVR Rev E1 1.5.6.1 TV1: Vizio 42" LCD 1080P 60HZ, Sage HD200, Yamaha 6.1 TV2: Samsung 26" LCD720P 60HZ, Sage HD200, TV Sound Network: Airlink 300N to DLINK DAP-1522 to Sage HD200 |
#129
|
||||
|
||||
For those interested, geektonic reports that Windows 7 can use the HD-PVR through some workarounds:
http://www.geektonic.com/2009/02/hau...ia-center.html Now this was posted in Feb and I know nothing about whether or not this actually works. I just noted the article and thought I would pass along. |
#130
|
|||
|
|||
What are your hardware specs?
|
#131
|
||||
|
||||
I tried VMC7 on my test machine, which is fairly low end. It was easy to install and visually looked wonderful. Then I tried to play some videos and it crashed and burned. Experiment over.
![]()
__________________
Sage Server: 8th gen Intel based system w/32GB RAM running Ubuntu Linux, HDHomeRun Prime with cable card for recording. Runs headless. Accessed via RD when necessary. Four HD-300 Extenders. |
#132
|
||||
|
||||
Are you asking for my specs? If so, Pent D 2.8ghz, 4GB ram, HVR-2250 and a Radeon HD 4350 512MB video card (recently upgraded from a Radeon HD 3400; got the new card from Newegg for $25 after rebate). With W7MC playing HDTV, cpu usage is about 10-20%. No issues to report with crashing and the video card handles HD very well...channel changing is smooth, playing new video starts quickly and there is no stutter. Also, the picture I get with the same hardware and W7MC is clearer than what I get with Sage using the PowerDVD 9 Ultra codecs, which tend to use a little more CPU horsepower than W7MC. There are also a couple of analog channels (CBS and NBC) that using Sage I got some distortion (ghosting and lines in the picture) that I didn't get with the cable box I am returning and I don't get with W7MC. Not sure how W7MC picks up the signal better and/or fixes the video but it does.
So for what I am using it for (no blue-ray, no encrypted cable, media center extender for TV in the den), W7MC works very well...thus my [unpopular] vote for "kicks ass." |
#133
|
|||
|
|||
Quote:
It's pretty likely that you'll get more who disagree with you though on these forums because many (or most) who are using SageTV know what MS Media Center can do and decided against it because of certain limitations. Probably some of those limitations have been "removed" with the improvements of W7, but many have not. That doesn't mean W7 MC isn't a great software and it also doesn't mean MS won't steal away a few more HTPC users - it just means SageTV still has many advantages (some disadvantages also of course) for the HTPC user and many of those people who prefer SageTV happen to spend some time on these forums ![]() |
#134
|
|||
|
|||
![]() Quote:
I have no plans on going to Windows 7, or MC until the normal year plus of hell is over. I was running vista on 1GB, but found that the page swapping was so bad it was unusable. With 4GB I can record one Mpeg2 HW assisted encoder while watching a recorded one. (Linux version runs well on 2GB). I am not using EVR, I am using the Direct X, but EVR is supported. If that is the only reason for using Vista, I would gladly go back to XP. Can someone exucate me on EVR, and if I am good without it now, i figure I will get even better performance out of XP than Vista. BTW, Thanks to the support Guru's on this site. I have a fully functioning SageTV, with the Dyanmic menu STVI installed and Multi-pane menu's enabled and I love it. It would be very very hard to top SageTV IMHO. (I just got $135 for my Dlink DSM-520 on Ebay... Geez did that suck! That was a $100 loss, but sticking with SageTv really paid off. I love it.) I wish I could replace my Fios DVR with another SageTV PVR. The Fios DVR is horrible after being used to the Direct-TV R20, and its predecessor Sony SAT-T60 Tivo unit. I compare the SAT-T60, which was very very popular to the SageTv PVR. I think it is right up there. ![]() ![]() Mark PS. Has anyone replaced their Fios (160GB Drive/20 Hours of Hi-Def Sad POS PVR) with SageTV? I was thinking perhaps I can connect the Fios PVR output to a second SageTV, and control it via a Blaster? Anyone? There is nothing I like about the Fios DVR. Even the guide is gross. Worse.. It has very buggy. Like you pause channel 4 news at 11pm at 11:15. The PVR kicks in to record on the SAME or Different channel at 11:30, you lose your buffer. So if you were watching a 2.5 hour movie and you paused it with 25 mins ot go to the end climax, and the system kicks in to record on the other tuner, it wipes your stored buffer out and brings you to live on the channel you are on!! What a POS!! Many updates and they can't fix it! ![]() Thanks!
__________________
Sage PVR: "Pandora MP945-DR ITX System" Intel core Duo 2 x 1.8Ghz, 4GB 667Mhz DDram, SATA 500GB 7200RPM Drive, DVD+-RW, DVI-HDMI HD out, Component RGB Video out/S-Video out, TOS Optical 5.1 Audo out, USB2.0 external Hauppauge WIN-TV HVR-1950 |
#135
|
||||
|
||||
defilm, I understand your frustration. W7 is kinda like the Vista MS should have released. Like when Win 95 was issued, it was such a piece of crap, Win 98 was really the release of the stable Win 95. XP, I think was MS's greatest success story. More stable from the getgo and lived on for several years and is still the preferred OS for many. Vista's release certainly had its issues and critcisms. One of the fixes of W7 is to be a little more efficent on the use of RAM and other resources. My expectation is people will be happier with W7 than they were/are with Vista. From what I can tell, it is using the Vista drivers without issue so there should be some good/stable compatibility out of the gate that Vista did not have when it was released. Some people wait until SP1 is out before they move to a new OS so that many of the bugs are worked out so that may be a good option for you.
I am using the RC of W7 and have to say, I haven't had any issues, runs like it was intended to...although mileage may vary for others.
__________________
SageTV 7.0.0.23, P5Q-EM Motherboard, 2.5Ghz Quad Core, Windows 7 x64, HVR-2250, 8GB RAM, 1TB HD, 2 HD-200 Extenders |
#136
|
|||
|
|||
i'm testing out the Win7 RC x64 now, and even though haven't gotten my HDPVR to work with it yet, gotta say that i'm not overly thrilled with the MC interface yet, though i haven't played with it in-depth.
Granted, I do have my share of SageTV problems (playing DVDs (real and from VIDEO_TS on my hard drive) and getting no-playback region code errors, the UI crashing at random when minimizing/maximizing, seeking problems, long delay on changing channels), some of which i'm sure aren't necessarily SageTV's fault..at the moment I don't think I'd pick MC over SageTV. -Tony |
#137
|
||||||||||
|
||||||||||
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
![]() Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
![]() |
#138
|
|||
|
|||
I know many of you like the horrible stock SageTV UI. Put in one more vote for a revampled UI in SageTV 7. As I said before, just rip-off the Windows 7Media Center UI. Don't have to put a lot of time researching or designing. Just code it up.
|
#139
|
||||
|
||||
Probably easier said than done. W7MC has a lot of nice overlays, transitions, graphics, etc. I would think these would be difficult to replicate and the cost of doing so may have little benefit for if it's the UI that's important, MC probably already has them beat. I think the focus on doing the things MC can't/won't is probably the best strategy, although easier "skinning" of Sage might be a good idea. Would be nice if you don't like blue to go with a different color scheme, etc.
__________________
SageTV 7.0.0.23, P5Q-EM Motherboard, 2.5Ghz Quad Core, Windows 7 x64, HVR-2250, 8GB RAM, 1TB HD, 2 HD-200 Extenders |
#140
|
|||
|
|||
To me, the only place that Windows 7 has it over Sage is in the setup of tuners. I was quite amazed at how easy it was. I had 2 dual tuners (analog and digital) and it found all four, scanned for channels, and got the guide right for all tuners, with only a couple of clicks from me.
But that's it. While the UI is slick, I find it cumbersome. So while I would love a new UI choice for Sage, VMC/W7 ain't it. Now if Sage could copy the tuner setup mechanism, THAT would be cool. |
![]() |
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
!! HDPVR support in Windows Media Center !! | jerryt | General Discussion | 16 | 02-24-2009 09:43 PM |
Using Windows Media Center as Client | barogers | SageTV Software | 4 | 12-28-2008 05:43 PM |
Windows 7 Media Center details released! | LehighBri | General Discussion | 8 | 10-29-2008 07:02 AM |
Sage Client and Windows Media Center PC... | robhix | SageTV Software | 2 | 02-05-2008 02:29 PM |
Need help want to use sage tv and windows media center | gav | Hardware Support | 1 | 03-09-2006 11:25 PM |